Prepaid Interest And Escrow Funding Are Not Fees

Two lines near the bottom of a closing statement regularly account for a large share of the cash a borrower has to produce, and neither is a fee. Prepaid interest is interest you would owe anyway, settled a few weeks early. The initial escrow deposit is your own tax and insurance money, sitting in an account with your name attached to it.

Treating them as cost is the single most common way a closing statement gets misread. It inflates the total, it makes a lender look expensive for reasons unconnected to the lender, and it produces the wrong winner in any comparison.

Prepaid interest: a function of the calendar

Mortgage interest is customarily paid in arrears — a payment made at the start of a month covers interest that accrued during the previous month. When a loan funds mid-month, there is a stub period between funding and the start of the first full payment cycle, and interest for those days is collected at closing.

That is all the line is. It is per-diem interest for a known number of days at your own rate on your own balance.

Worked example, assumptions stated. Assume a loan of 100,000 at an annual rate of 6 per cent, and assume the lender computes per-diem on a 365-day basis. These figures are illustrative and are not observed market levels; no lender or product is implied. The daily accrual is 100,000 × 0.06 ÷ 365, roughly 16.44. Fund on the 27th of a 30-day month and four days are collected, about 66. Fund on the 3rd and twenty-eight days are collected, about 460. The second closing statement will show a larger total. It is not a more expensive loan. You have simply prepaid interest that the first borrower will pay a month later instead.

Two practical consequences follow.

Never compare two estimates that assume different closing dates without normalising for this — a point made in the section A comparison method.

And remember that on many home-secured transactions a rescission period applies before funds may be disbursed, which pushes the funding date out past the signing date. If you are timing a closing to reduce the prepaid line, that waiting period is part of the calendar, and it also means a delay in the closing changes the number.

Escrow funding: an opening balance

Where taxes and insurance are escrowed, the servicer must be holding enough by the time each bill falls due. At closing, an opening balance is funded — some months of tax and insurance, plus a cushion the servicer is permitted to hold against timing mismatches. Federal rules cap that cushion, which is why escrow deposits, though sometimes large, are bounded rather than arbitrary.

The size of the deposit depends almost entirely on where you sit in your jurisdiction's tax calendar. Close shortly before a large tax instalment is due and the deposit is high, because the account must be funded to meet it. Close just after and it is lower. Again: timing, not price.

This money remains yours. It is applied to your bills, it is subject to an annual analysis, and any surplus above the permitted threshold is refunded to you under the applicable rule. A shortage identified at the annual analysis works the other way and raises the monthly payment, which is worth anticipating rather than being surprised by.

Note that not every equity product escrows. Many second-lien loans and lines do not, leaving you to pay taxes and insurance directly. That removes the deposit from the closing statement but not the obligation from your year, and a borrower moving from an escrowed to a non-escrowed structure should budget the difference deliberately.

Where they sit, and what they do to the total

On the standardised form, prepaids and the initial escrow payment occupy their own sections, separate from loan costs. That separation is deliberate and it is the reader's friend. Total loan costs is the figure that reflects what the transaction costs to arrange. Total closing costs adds the government items, the prepaids and the escrow deposit, and is therefore a cash-flow figure rather than a price.

The three-bucket sort exists for exactly this reason: judge the lender on the bucket the lender controls.

The one thing worth checking

Neither line is negotiable, but both are checkable, and errors do occur.

Verify the per-diem: loan amount times rate, divided by 360 or 365 depending on the lender's convention, times the number of days between funding and the start of the first full cycle. If the number on the form does not reconcile, ask which day count and which funding date were assumed.

Verify the escrow deposit against your actual tax and insurance bills and the next due dates. A deposit built on an estimated tax figure — common where a property has been reassessed — can be materially off, and the correction will land in your monthly payment later.

And when the cash-to-close figure alarms you, decompose it before reacting. Part of it is cost. A meaningful part of it is your own money, moving a few weeks earlier than it otherwise would. That distinction does not make the borrowing safe — the loan is secured on your home either way — but it does make the comparison honest.

Related entries

• The Appraisal, And What Happens When It Comes In Low